MATT BRESCIANI
  • Home
  • About Me
  • EDL 820
  • EC&I 832
  • EC&I 830
  • EC&I 833
  • EC&I 834
  • Contact

Learning & Knowledge Theories

9/27/2020

6 Comments

 
Picture
Source: www.tenor.com
While I've enjoyed every one of the Ed Tech classes over the past three semesters, I think our class this week may have been one of favourites. While it may not have been as flashy or engaging as some of the previous classes, I enjoyed this particular class (as well as writing this post) because it led me down a path of self reflection. If I'm being honest, I haven't thought about theories of knowledge or learning since my undergrad when we first learned about them. Taking the time to go through each of these theories, was quite refreshing as it enabled me to critically evaluate the type of educator I am.  

What Type of Educator Was I?

As Alec, took us on the tour of Knowledge Theories, I immediately connected with the Behaviourist theory of learning. While this may not be the theory that I would align myself with anymore, it definitely would fit with the teacher I was nine years ago in my first year of teaching. Looking back, I utilized this theory in everything I did as a first-year educator - especially classroom management. I was definitely of the mindset that my role as an educator was to fill my students with the knowledge, and as a result, I did "deliver" more lessons to my students, than actually "experience" the learning with them. This was probably most evident in my Math lessons as I was very concerned with how to produce the desired results (right answers) from my students, than anything else. As a result, the delivery of my lessons reflected this and I can't imagine they were the most engaging lessons for my students.  

​In addition to utilizing the behaviourist theory for curricular means, I also found myself gravitating to this model for classroom management as well. While I still believe that the behaviourist theory fits in this domain today, I think I approached it a little differently in the past than I do now. In the early stages of my career, I remember using tools like Class Dojo and other behaviour tools to help achieve the desired positive behaviour in my classroom. Essentially awarding points for positive behaviours, and withdrawing for negative ones. As I will talk about a little later - I learned that this particular method wasn't the best (especially the withdrawals for negatives) and moved away from Class Dojo and other similar models quite quickly, and shifted towards a more proactive practice instead of a reactive one.  
Picture
Source: www.csmonitor.com

Where Am I Now?

Jumping to the present, I believe that I have certainly changed in many ways since my first year of teaching. I understand that my beliefs and style have certainly shifted due to a combination of my experiences in the classroom, great mentors, and fellow colleagues. As I mentioned earlier, at the onset of my career I would definitely have classified myself as a Behaviouralist, but now I'm not sure if I would classify myself in only one of the theories. After examining a plethora of theories in Tuesday's class, it's become apparent that my current teaching practice has changed and now reflects a combination of theories as opposed to one singular belief.

1) Experiential Learning
​
This learning theory is definitely one that I see the most reflected in my classroom and a major part of my belief as an educator. As Lisa expertly mentioned in her post this week, experiential learning is very relationship-centered and these experiences with others can be "the most meaningful learning tool". I definitely agree with Lisa as I firmly believe that in order for learning to occur, students need to feel safe, comfortable, and connected to their teacher and classmates. As a result, much of my learning opportunities provide the students with the ability to communicate, collaborate form relationships with one another while they are learning. 

I also believe that students need to feel engaged with the content of their learning, and a "hands-on" approach can be an incredible support to help students connect with the course content. A number of years ago, I remember having a discussion with Trevor, (and current classmate of ours) who was a colleague of mine, regarding my Science lesson from the day. I was disheartened and a little burned out because my students just weren't connecting with the content I was trying to teach them, and as a result, was dealing with disengaged students. Trevor, an energetic young teacher who was fresh out of university at the time, shared some great wisdom with me - it might be helpful if I used a more "hands-on", experiential approach with the content. While I never felt that I was a boring teacher, it was apparent that the method I was utilizing may have worked for a number of years prior, just wasn't cutting it anymore. Trevor gave me some great ideas for this lesson, which in turn, inspired me to reflect on my current practices, and ultimately led me to a more experiential teaching practice. To this day, I still credit Trevor for rejuvenating my teaching practices and helping me to become the educator I am today.  
​
2) Cognitivism
While I would certainly say that Experiential Learning is the largest theory that impacts my current teaching practice, it's evident that I've also got some sprinkles of cognitivism in there as well. As was explained in the article "Description of Cognitivism" by Mohammed Rhalmi, the learning process for this theory views students as "active participants in the learning process" and not just minds to be "filled with knowledge". Not only does this idea also connect with some of the fundamental beliefs of Experientialism, but it also outlines the idea that students are not tied to one strategy for learning, but may use various ones to "construct their personal understanding".  


3) Behaviourism
​
Even though I've shifted away from this particular theory, it's still clear to me that Behaviorism does have a place within my teaching practice - it's just far less prevalent than it was ten years ago. In the present, it's clear that while not utilized for curricular purposes, behaviourism still plays a major role in my classroom, more specifically, for classroom management and procedures. As I mentioned earlier, in the past I used this approach in my classroom through the addition and subtraction of points to help achieve the desired behaviours in my classroom. However, this approach was far more reactive than proactive, which is the best way to describe how my utilization of behaviourism has shifted. Instead of using this reactive method, my focus is now on highlighting and using behaviour specific praise for the positive behaviours within my classroom.

​For this, I utilize our school-wide SWPBIS (School-Wide Positive Behaviour Interventions and Supports) framework to highlight the specific positive behaviour that the student demonstrated. ex. "Thank you for showing respect holding the door open for your classmates". Staff all have tickets that can then be handed out to the student when they notice one of these positive behaviours, which in turn, are entered for a school-wide draw at the start of each week. While it could be argued that we are just bribing the students, I far prefer this method as you don't need to hand out tickets every time, as the goal of this strategy to use behaviour specific praise when we see these positive behaviours. This has also helped me as a teacher, in changing the way that I view behaviour in our school. Rather than only addressing the negative behaviours I see, I am now routinely looking and identifying the positive ones far more often.   
Picture
A sample of the tickets I hand out

​Overall, I found it quite interesting to reflect and see how my teaching practices have changed over the last ten years.  It also makes me wonder, if I changed this much in the first third of my career, what will my teaching practices look like in another ten or twenty years?  Will the change or stay the same? I guess only time will tell.  Check back in the year 2040 for my next update!

6 Comments
Melinda
9/27/2020 06:01:43 pm

Hi Matt,
Thank you so much for sharing how you changed as a teacher. I think that when we are at the very beginning of our careers, there is so much to stress about. I will never forget how hard it was for me to deal with my anxiety when the teacher coach at that time, Mike Chase came in to observe my class. After the class, I was waiting for him to tell me all that I did wrong and to my biggest surprise he only had positive things to share. At that time, I felt that I was truly supported and it meant the world to me. I feel that you found that support system in Trevor. It is truly wonderful when we have colleagues to share ideas with and learn from.

In one of my schools we also implemented the SWPBIS and it made a huge change in the students' behaviour. Just like you, I have noticed that I started focusing on the positives. We are not handing out tickets right now, but I make sure I let the students know when they set a good example. Sometimes I feel they are both surprised and happy when someone notices them. Since at the end of the day, they may not remember what we taught them that day, but they will always remember how we made them feel.

Looking forward to reading your 2040 reflection! :)

Reply
Leigh
9/27/2020 06:25:46 pm

Matt,

Great reflection! Like Melinda, I'm waiting on that 2040 reflection as well! I also appreciated this blog prompt. I have only been teaching for four years, but it really did surprise me how much growth has happened in such a short period of time. I remember being a new teacher and just barely keeping my head above water. I was SO focused on meeting outcomes as quickly as I could. I really wasn't experiencing any learning with my students. Now, I feel like I've learned to let go and let my students take more control of their own learning... Needless to say, it makes for a more enjoyable experience for everyone!

I love the concept of the SWPBIS! I like that it is a school-wide effort and it acquaints students with teachers that may not teach in their grade level area, which results in a positive school community.

Thanks for sharing!

Reply
Daina Seymour
9/27/2020 08:14:33 pm

I definitely see the teaching "bromance" that you and Trevor have. It's so important to have colleagues, and likely friends, that have a positive impact on your teaching practices and overall philosophy. If we didn't change over time, we likely wouldn't be addressing our student needs.
As you said, there really isn't one type of theory that we stick to, more so one that we may favour and over time change as we gain our own experiences. I can say that even after 15 years of teaching, I have come across a new student this year that is throwing some curve balls at me and I've swung and missed quite a few times already. I have learned that collaborating with other professionals has helped to get my swing in check and I'm starting to foul some of those curve balls off. This is progress I would say.
The exploration of these learning theories has demonstrated that students will respond differently to the learning/teaching approaches that we use, which means we should use more than one theory to address our students' needs.

Reply
lisa frazer
9/28/2020 11:29:05 am

It is incredible to look back and see how we grow and change. You and Trevor are lucky to have eachother. I, too, have had a great learning experience from young "fresh" teachers! We always have something to learn and something to give! That's the ebb and flow in life! Your reward tickets are a great system. It is much better to look for "positives" than negatives! I like to reward my class as a whole with usually outdoor activity to keep them active (plus it's a reward for me as well) and a great way to get to know kids as they see you in a different light when you participate with them in activities!

Reply
Tammy
9/28/2020 02:30:36 pm

Thanks for sharing Matt! I too like to talk with and see other teachers in action. It really gives us a new outlook on how we may approach and teach something. We can so many different ways to engage out students, but sometimes it takes a 'new' perspective. Something you might be interested in reading is the book "Teach Like a Pirate." Dave Burgess is all about getting students engaged. I think some of his approaches might interested you. Thanks again for sharing.

Reply
Jennifer
9/28/2020 07:55:36 pm

Hey Matt,
I enjoyed reading your post. I was thinking about SWPBIS when I was writing my blog post over the weekend. That is definitely a good example of a behaviourist approach. I'll admit, I've never been to sure what I think of the ticket system, but as you mentioned, I do like the use of positive language to reinforce behaviour.
When I started teaching, we were all hooked on "The First Days of School" Harry Wong has been very successful teaching behaviourist practices to help teachers set the year up for success.

Reply



Leave a Reply.

    Author

    Write something about yourself. No need to be fancy, just an overview.

    Archives

    November 2020
    October 2020
    September 2020

    Categories

    All

    RSS Feed

Powered by Create your own unique website with customizable templates.
  • Home
  • About Me
  • EDL 820
  • EC&I 832
  • EC&I 830
  • EC&I 833
  • EC&I 834
  • Contact